Avril Lavigne - Song Thief???
July 11th 2007 02:33
Avril Lavigne is having a bad month in July. Song writers Tommy Dunbar and James Gangwaller that Avril's song "Girlfriend" is a rip off of their "I want to be your boyfriend" which was performed by 70's rock group The Rubinoos.
In another slap in the face, songwriter Chantal Kraviazuk riduculed the notion that Avril Lavigne writes all her own songs, saying "Avril doesn't really sit and write songs by herself or anything."
Chantal also claimed that she wrote a song for Avril's second album called "Contagious" that Avril knocked back. However, another song called "Contagious" showed up on her 3rd album that was credited as being written by Avril and Evan Taubenfield.
Avril hit back, posting this message on her MySpace page
Here's a cute Youtube clip showcasing the two songs. Take a listen.
Personally, I think "Girlfriend" has more in common with Toni Basil's "Mickey", but hey, I'm no expert.
However it looks as though Avril is going to have to answer more questions about the originality of her songs with some noticing that Avril's song "I Don't Have to Try", from her current album sounds remarkably similar to Peaches song "I'm the Kinda".
How do we know that, I hear you ask? Well, a concerned listener has made a Youtube video showcasing the two songs. Listen for yourself.
Ooops, sounds to me like the dumb-ass has ripped off the musical genius of Peaches. Not that I can blame her. Peaches rocks.........Avril sucks. But c'mon Avril, a little originality please!!!!
In another slap in the face, songwriter Chantal Kraviazuk riduculed the notion that Avril Lavigne writes all her own songs, saying "Avril doesn't really sit and write songs by herself or anything."
Chantal also claimed that she wrote a song for Avril's second album called "Contagious" that Avril knocked back. However, another song called "Contagious" showed up on her 3rd album that was credited as being written by Avril and Evan Taubenfield.
Avril hit back, posting this message on her MySpace page
To my dear media, friends, and fans,
You may have heard some news that two guys who wrote for some band from the 1970s I have never in my life heard of called the “Rubinoos” are trying to sue me. They have a song called “I Want To Be Your Boyfriend” that has no musical similarities to the song “Girlfriend” that Luke Gottwald and I wrote together. They claim that a small part of the lyrics are the same and are saying that I took these from them. I had never heard this song in my life and their claim is based on 5 words! All songs share similar lyrics and emotions. As humans we speak one language.
Off the top of my head, two other songs that I can immediately think of with this type of lyric are “Hey, hey, you, you get off of my cloud” by the Rolling Stones and “Hey little girl I want to be your boyfriend” by the Ramones. Simply put, I have been falsely accused of ripping their song off. Luke and I have done nothing wrong and there is no merit to their claim.
And slap in the face #2
I was going to be the bigger person and not reply when I read Chantal Kreviazuk’s article in Performing Songwriter magazine. Now that all the media have caught on to her little interview, I need to speak. Chantal’s comments are damaging to my reputation and a clear defamation of my character and I am considering taking legal action. Chantal has accused me of taking a song idea from her because I happen to have a song on my new record with the same title.
For the record, I wrote a song with Evan Taubenfeld which coincidentally has the same title as a song Chantal had sent me a few years ago. Our songs have no similarities and opposite meanings, i.e. different lyrics, different melody, different genres. In Chantal’s own words “the only similarity is in the title.” I originally wrote this with Evan for his record and I ended up with it. Funny enough when I decided to put “Contagious” on my album we had to change the words from “she” to “he” in order for it to work on my record. There are hundreds of songs out there with the title “Contagious,” 75 on iTunes alone.
Chantal has also made false accusations about my writing skills. I am so over this topic. This letter is not about this. I am not going to sit here and defend my writing skills. I don’t have to prove anything to anyone. I know who I am and what I have done and accomplished and no one can take that away from me.
My decision to discontinue working with Chantal after co-writing together on my second record was simply based on the fact that we had no hits together. That is why her name is not on this record, despite her numerous attempts to be included, which were always denied. From my perspective this is a clear case of bitterness. Chantal is upset that she didn’t get to be a part of my record. She did email me after the article came out apologizing and I forgive her but I have to put the truth out there so my fans are not confused by these false accusations.
Let it be crystal clear that I have not ripped anyone off or done anything wrong. I have never had to deal with anything publicly like this and surely never wanted to. I do not deserve this negative press and attention. I take pride in the songs that I write and appreciate the opportunities to work with some great writers and musicians.
My fans have been so dedicated to my music and it is because of them that I have this amazing career. Thank you again to my fans for continuing to be so supportive. This is a very positive time for me in my life. I have a very successful career and I feel very lucky to have accomplished all that I have. I am so thankful every day.
I would like to say more but my lawyers have advised me not to. Why is it when you get to a certain level people want to attack you?…. and now I have said my piece.
Avril
You may have heard some news that two guys who wrote for some band from the 1970s I have never in my life heard of called the “Rubinoos” are trying to sue me. They have a song called “I Want To Be Your Boyfriend” that has no musical similarities to the song “Girlfriend” that Luke Gottwald and I wrote together. They claim that a small part of the lyrics are the same and are saying that I took these from them. I had never heard this song in my life and their claim is based on 5 words! All songs share similar lyrics and emotions. As humans we speak one language.
Off the top of my head, two other songs that I can immediately think of with this type of lyric are “Hey, hey, you, you get off of my cloud” by the Rolling Stones and “Hey little girl I want to be your boyfriend” by the Ramones. Simply put, I have been falsely accused of ripping their song off. Luke and I have done nothing wrong and there is no merit to their claim.
And slap in the face #2
I was going to be the bigger person and not reply when I read Chantal Kreviazuk’s article in Performing Songwriter magazine. Now that all the media have caught on to her little interview, I need to speak. Chantal’s comments are damaging to my reputation and a clear defamation of my character and I am considering taking legal action. Chantal has accused me of taking a song idea from her because I happen to have a song on my new record with the same title.
For the record, I wrote a song with Evan Taubenfeld which coincidentally has the same title as a song Chantal had sent me a few years ago. Our songs have no similarities and opposite meanings, i.e. different lyrics, different melody, different genres. In Chantal’s own words “the only similarity is in the title.” I originally wrote this with Evan for his record and I ended up with it. Funny enough when I decided to put “Contagious” on my album we had to change the words from “she” to “he” in order for it to work on my record. There are hundreds of songs out there with the title “Contagious,” 75 on iTunes alone.
Chantal has also made false accusations about my writing skills. I am so over this topic. This letter is not about this. I am not going to sit here and defend my writing skills. I don’t have to prove anything to anyone. I know who I am and what I have done and accomplished and no one can take that away from me.
My decision to discontinue working with Chantal after co-writing together on my second record was simply based on the fact that we had no hits together. That is why her name is not on this record, despite her numerous attempts to be included, which were always denied. From my perspective this is a clear case of bitterness. Chantal is upset that she didn’t get to be a part of my record. She did email me after the article came out apologizing and I forgive her but I have to put the truth out there so my fans are not confused by these false accusations.
Let it be crystal clear that I have not ripped anyone off or done anything wrong. I have never had to deal with anything publicly like this and surely never wanted to. I do not deserve this negative press and attention. I take pride in the songs that I write and appreciate the opportunities to work with some great writers and musicians.
My fans have been so dedicated to my music and it is because of them that I have this amazing career. Thank you again to my fans for continuing to be so supportive. This is a very positive time for me in my life. I have a very successful career and I feel very lucky to have accomplished all that I have. I am so thankful every day.
I would like to say more but my lawyers have advised me not to. Why is it when you get to a certain level people want to attack you?…. and now I have said my piece.
Avril
Here's a cute Youtube clip showcasing the two songs. Take a listen.
Personally, I think "Girlfriend" has more in common with Toni Basil's "Mickey", but hey, I'm no expert.
However it looks as though Avril is going to have to answer more questions about the originality of her songs with some noticing that Avril's song "I Don't Have to Try", from her current album sounds remarkably similar to Peaches song "I'm the Kinda".
How do we know that, I hear you ask? Well, a concerned listener has made a Youtube video showcasing the two songs. Listen for yourself.
Ooops, sounds to me like the dumb-ass has ripped off the musical genius of Peaches. Not that I can blame her. Peaches rocks.........Avril sucks. But c'mon Avril, a little originality please!!!!
| 77 |
| Vote |
Subscribe to this blog
























Comment by Louie
Climate Forum
Climate Red
randomthoughts
Phil's Wellness Tips
I also think you will find that half the songs going around are ripped off from something else to a degree...especially as you get older and you think you've heard a song before then you realise its just a partial rip off of a song you loved in the Eighties.......I feel horrible saying it but...... I hope she gets sued but maybe if one does they'll have to come up with original music and talented people can have careers again, not just sell their
soulsmusic to "names" for next to nothing because yo uneed to be famous to sell records....and breatheComment by Kleonaptra
Kalikapsychosis
Bless her little cotton socks. Wether she has or has not ripped off, one thing will always be true - The higher you get, the more people want to knock you down!
Comment by KylieW
Celebrity Obsession
I doubt that the guys who wrote the boyfriend song will get money. I just don't think her song is that much of a rip off of it. But you're right so many songs are blatant rip offs of an old sound.
Hiya Kleo,
You're right, the tall poppy syndrome never goes away. I hate myself for it, but I do find girlfriend to be an addictive song.......particularly the japanese version of it. I love it. But Avril, I just can't stand. Mind you, she's been going out of her way to get publicity lately (giving her opinions about Britney to anyone who would listen in order to get herself noticed).....and this is the result
Good to see you
Kylie
Comment by Mrs M
Mum's Word
Yeah I heard that Girlfriend sounded like Micky.
You write songs with a particular sound and particular elements to evoke a particular emotion..so there are going to similarities I suppose.
I don't know...neither are my songs so I'm not going to lose sleep over it.
I've got 5 kids in the house today so I'm a little frazzled
Love & stuff
Mrs M
Comment by KylieW
Celebrity Obsession
Crikey, 5 kids!!!!! I'd be more than a little frazzled!!!
Kylie
Comment by Aimzster
Health and Beauty
Reality TV
The Jeepney Stop
Comment by Nina
Comment by KylieW
Celebrity Obsession
Nina - I know, at least go for something cool. Don't get me wrong, Mickey rocked. But it's hardly got street cred!
Comment by Anonymous
Just imagine you being a songwriter. You created a song by yourself. But after about a month after your song was published, these mob of people accuse you of being a thief. Accuse you of stealing a song from the seventies, the years you weren't even born. Is this fair!?
Mind you, these mob of people should back off to their hells
Comment by KylieW
Celebrity Obsession
I actually don't think Avril's song does sound like that 70's sound that she's accused of plagiarising. I think it sounds way more like Mickey by Toni Basil, but it's not enough to be considered plagiarism. That's more coincidence. Though I do find it funny that a girl who claims to be so 'punk' is writing songs that sound like 80's bubblegum pop!
Kylie
Comment by ganzoed
Comment by KylieW
Celebrity Obsession
In this case (and it pains me to say it, because I really do dislike Avril) I think it's all a storm in a teacup. I think there's similarities, but she hasn't stolen the song. Used riffs and hooks. Sure. But she's not alone in doing that.
As for the Stones.....that's just ridiculous. Surely Mick has enough cash and doesn't need to sue people for ridiculous claims like that!!!
Thanks for stopping by
Kylie
Comment by Anonymous